Please Click on the Appropriate Carrier Below or Call the Company Directly to Make a Payment Bristol West: 1-888-888-0080 Foremost: 1-888-383-4244 Grinnell Mutual: 800-362-2041 Hagerty: 1-888-220-9565 Kingston Mutual: 815-784-5657 Auto: 1-888-293-5108 Home: 1-888-325-1190 Health: 1-888-781-0585 PLN Mail a Check: 201 Lincoln Statue Drive Dixon, IL 61021 Progressive: 1-866-671-4405